← All posts

Arrow vs MyFitnessPal for lifters: which one should you use?

Arrow and MyFitnessPal compared for people who lift, on what each app does when your lifts or weight stall, food logging, workout logging, free versions and price. Facts checked 2026-11-17.

Pick MyFitnessPal if you want to start free, you eat out a lot and need the biggest food database (20.5M+ foods, restaurant dishes included), or you're on Android. Pick Arrow if you lift on an iPhone and want your workouts, food and weight in one app that connects them, so your calories, protein, carbs and fats update on their own when your training stalls, your weight gain stalls, or you're gaining too quickly. If you don't lift, MyFitnessPal is the better fit and Arrow isn't worth paying for.

I make Arrow. Every MyFitnessPal claim below comes from MyFitnessPal's own help center, pricing page or App Store listing, checked November 17, 2026. Spot something out of date? Email support@arrowfitnessapp.com.

01Who is each app built for?

MyFitnessPal is a food diary first. It's built for anyone counting calories, lifter or not, and its biggest strength is how quickly you can find a food. It has a real free version, a huge database, and Premium tools like barcode scanning, Meal Scan (photo logging), voice logging and, on iPhone, an AI Coach. It logs workouts too, including weight and reps for each set through its Workout Routines feature.

Arrow is built for people who lift and are trying to change their body: cutting, bulking, or recomping (losing fat and gaining muscle at the same time). Your workout log, food log and weigh-ins feed one set of targets, so what happens in the gym can change what you're told to eat.

Arrow isn't for you if you want a free app, you're not on an iPhone, or you mainly want meal plans and grocery lists.

02What happens when your progress stalls?

This is where the two apps really differ, so here's one made-up lifter (an illustration, not a real user) run through both.

You're 185 lb, on a lean bulk, eating about 2,900 calories a day. For three weeks your trend weight sits between 185.0 and 185.4, and your bench has been stuck at 205 x 8 for three sessions in a row. You logged every meal.

What you'd want to know MyFitnessPal Arrow
Is my weight actually flat? You log your weigh-ins and can view them on a Progress weight chart. MyFitnessPal doesn't publish a trend-weight method Every weigh-in is plotted against a trend line (Scale Weight vs Trend Weight), and Arrow Coach flags swings that are likely water
Is my bench stalled? Yes, if you log it as a Workout Routine: your sets, reps and weight are saved Yes: sets, reps, weight and reps in reserve (RIR) on every set, with history and PRs on each exercise
Does my calorie target change? Not on its own. Your goal comes from a formula, and MyFitnessPal offers to recalculate it after every 10 lb you record losing. You can edit the goal yourself any time Yes. The weekly check-in estimates what you actually burn from your weigh-ins and food log. Because weight gain stalled, Arrow updates calories, protein, carbs and fats on its own
Does the bench stall count for anything? Not toward your targets. Logged routines add an estimated calorie burn to that day, but your lifting numbers don't change your calorie or macro goals Yes. A training stall is one of the triggers for Arrow's automatic update

In MyFitnessPal, you'd notice both stalls yourself, decide the bulk needs more food, and raise the goal by hand. That works fine if you know what you're doing. In Arrow, the same two signals land in the same app, and the targets move without you doing the math. The full walkthrough is in how Arrow changes your macros when training stalls.

One limit worth knowing: Arrow's weekly check-in moves calories by at most 150 at a time and needs about 7 complete logged days plus 2 weigh-ins at least 7 days apart before it adjusts. We haven't published exactly how many stalled sessions trigger an update. More on how weight-trend targets work is in apps that adjust calories from your weight trend.

03Logging food

MyFitnessPal's database lists 20.5M+ foods, including restaurant dishes. If you eat out often or eat a lot of packaged food, that's a real advantage. Barcode scanning, Meal Scan and voice logging are on Premium, and the free version has ads.

Arrow's database is smaller (2.3M+ foods). Logging options are Smart Scan (photograph your plate), describing a meal in words or by voice, barcode scanning and search. Smart Scan asks before you log if a meal was likely cooked in oil, since that's where a lot of hidden calories come from. All of it is part of the one subscription.

04Logging workouts

MyFitnessPal does log lifting. Its Workout Routines feature lets you build routines and log weight and reps for each set, and those routines add an estimated calorie burn to your day. A standalone strength entry is saved too, but MyFitnessPal doesn't count calories for it. Per its help center, Workout Routines isn't available on the website or iPad app.

Arrow's workout side is a full gym log: your own routines or ones generated from your goal, equipment, days and session length, a rest timer, dropsets, RIR on each set, and next-weight suggestions. When you hit the top of your rep range on every set, the next session's target moves up (for example 145 x 12 becomes 150 x 10). How to read that kind of log is in how to track progressive overload.

05What does MyFitnessPal do better today?

  • A real free version. Basic food and fitness tracking costs nothing (with ads). Arrow has no free version.
  • The bigger food database, with restaurant dishes.
  • Android, web and wearables. MyFitnessPal runs on iPhone, Android and the web, and it supports Apple Watch and Wear OS. Arrow's latest features are iPhone only, and no Apple Watch app is listed.
  • Meal planning. Premium+ adds weekly meal plans, grocery lists and recipes. Arrow doesn't plan meals.

06Where does Arrow fall short?

  • No free version. There's a 7-day free trial, then one paid subscription, and the price shown in the App Store can vary.
  • The latest features are iPhone only.
  • No Apple Watch app.
  • A smaller food database than MyFitnessPal's.
  • We haven't published how many stalled sessions trigger an update, or how big each update is.

07What do they cost?

MyFitnessPal Free costs nothing. Premium is $79.99 a year or $19.99 a month, and Premium+ is $99.99 a year or $24.99 a month (US prices from MyFitnessPal's membership page).

Arrow has one paid subscription after a 7-day free trial. The price varies, so check the App Store listing rather than a number on a blog.

08When should you pick MyFitnessPal over Arrow?

  • You want to start free, or you only want to count calories.
  • You eat out a lot and want restaurant dishes in the database.
  • You're on Android, or you log from a computer.
  • You want meal plans and grocery lists.
  • You already know how to adjust your own calories when progress stalls, and you're happy to do it by hand.

09When should you pick Arrow over MyFitnessPal?

  • You lift on an iPhone and want one app for workouts, food and weight.
  • You want calories, protein, carbs and fats to update on their own when training stalls, weight gain stalls, or you're gaining too quickly, on a cut as well as a bulk.
  • You'd rather your targets come from your own weigh-ins and food log than from a formula.
  • You want next-weight suggestions and RIR in the same app as your macros.

If you're leaving MyFitnessPal but Arrow isn't the right fit, the other options are in the best MyFitnessPal alternatives for lifters.

10FAQ

Can MyFitnessPal track lifting?

Yes. Workout Routines saves weight and reps for each set and adds an estimated calorie burn. What it doesn't do is use your lifting numbers to change your calorie or macro targets.

Does MyFitnessPal adjust your calories automatically?

Not from your weight trend. Its goal comes from a formula, and its help center says it offers to recalculate that goal after every 10 lb of weight loss you record, and you can force a recalculation by updating your weight. It doesn't estimate what you actually burn from your weigh-ins.

Is there one app that replaces Hevy and MyFitnessPal?

Arrow is built to do both jobs on iPhone: a full lifting log and a food log with targets that update from your weight trend and your training. It's paid, and its food database is smaller than MyFitnessPal's, so it's the better swap for lifters than for people who only count calories.

Does Arrow have a free version?

No. Arrow has a 7-day free trial, then one paid subscription. MyFitnessPal has a free version with ads.

11Sources

Checked November 17, 2026.

This is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a professional before making changes that affect your health.